For these and other reasons, no other element comes even close to carbon for abundance, availability, potential for biogeochemical cycling, and appropriate bond energy and diversity. This isnt to discourage you sf-writing-types (and I know youre out there) from cooking up the Quantum Meat from elements other than carbon. Im just letting you know that itll be difficult, and that youll have to make allowances in your recipe, or those of us with a discerning palate are likely to choke on your efforts.
Next time, well take the basic principles of chemistry and use them to build biological molecules and basic cellular components. Bring your appetite.
In Memory of Lou Csontos